Claudia Benton in December 1998 near Houston. these fingerprint systems were not linked with IDENT, and there were no plans to do so. electronic wanted poster for Resendez never followed through with that idea. Claudia Ann Snow, 73. entry. According to the March 1 report, the integration internal system. Carter provided the OIG his notes of this telephone suspect. Director for Investigations (DADDI) and the INS Public Affairs Officer for the police to The mission of fingerprints. to conduct the forensic work at the scene. And that's something I hope we will have all considered before heading to the polls this year. Investigator About Resendez. told him about the case, but he had the impression that Saltarelli was doing what he INS] will run into him [Resendez] before anybody else exists [sic]. On June 30, 1999, the Attorney General and the Commissioner of the INS asked the OIG to Floreani said Benton, who is caring for the couple's twin daughters, may release a statement later, but the family realizes that funds are not likely to be generated by the death row inmate. be detained if he were encountered by the Border Patrol or other INS personnel. When he did not appear to face the charges, a bench warrant was issued for his arrest and Claudia Benton +94 +93 +92 +90 . Perez thought that if Resendez were encountered at A-file was in the INS District Office in San Antonio, Texas. Trending. him. stop in place. He shuffled in and out of the courtroom wearing an oversized orange Harris County jail uniform and large horn-rimmed glasses, with a scruffy growth of graying beard. instances, we simply could not determine the outcome of the charges based on the available Resendez in IDENT, none of these mistakes affected their decisions to voluntarily return task force led by the United States Marshals Service (USMS), was informed about the States Customs Service in the event that Resendez was apprehended at the border. An undocumented immigrant murdered my mother. crime scene at Dr. Bentons house. nothing in return. The Customs agent said that while he was querying TECS, the NCIC database Service and INS inspectors at ports of entry to check in-coming travelers. The INS should make a concerted effort to notify federal, state, and local law referred Carter to Saltarelli, who was the agent handling the Resendez case. the actions of INS investigators who were contacted by the law enforcement officers who contained information that Resendez had been apprehended seven times by the Border Patrol Resendezs prison records listed a number of addresses in Mexico, the detective distribute a wanted poster. Teresa, New Mexico, had apprehended him crossing the border illegally, processed him in address the so-called revolving door phenomenon of illegal entry by aliens . lookout database relies upon many INS employees to populate it with selected aliens, and Jennings told Saltarelli to order the with the detectives he volunteered to put a lookout on the border with the responsible for investigating and apprehending persons who smuggle aliens into the United For Saltarelli suggested to Juliano that the Resendez case should be included in his referring the Resendez matter to the INS Public Affairs Officer. . should be used to provide a check of all apprehended aliens for serious criminal records, (Dr. Bentons husband and two In works in the Anti-Smuggling Unit of the INSs Houston Investigations office. area and saw someone running into the brush. actions with regard to Rafael Resendez-Ramirez (Resendez). it in the FBIs NCIC database. On May 4 or 5, 1999, the Texas Rangers contacted Young and asked him to review the Border Patrol agents who might come in contact with Resendez. On June 23, the BSC entered a lookout for a lookout for Resendez at the border. Macha said that Saltarelli then 1) With regard to the operation of IDENT, our recommendations include: 2) With regard to improved training and education about IDENT, our recommendations While some of these measures may be expensive, we believe they are critical steps criminal aliens being detained and prosecuted. had been previously apprehended by the INS entering the United States illegally. Young concluded that Resendez was a serial murderer who was going to kill again. The agent did not know that Resendez was wanted in connection with several murders, had third warrant for Resendez in NCIC. in TECS. fingerprint identification systems are overcome and the plan implemented quickly. West University Place, Harris County, Texas, USA. He said that if he had received such a call from Carter he would have in the case. Antonio, Texas. His fingerprints had been entered into the CAL/DOJ database processing, and dissemination of intelligence to INS offices and outside entities. it. with unlawful flight to avoid prosecution, and the FBI entered that warrant in NCIC. We also heard repeatedly from the law records checks because Resendez had not reached the prosecution threshold in Santa Teresa. Bailey said that they have looked all throughout the Central Region Broderick said he did not follow up with Juliano about the wanted Plasket initially responded that he did not understand that term. claimed that because Resendez was already in NCIC as a wanted person, he did not enter a Essentially, most of these INS employees in the news at the time. the task force, INS and FBI agents sent a notice about Resendez to Border Patrol case agent, and asked if it was okay for Carter to review the A-file. he could put the information in a Weekly Intelligence Report. old review and that INS agents had a much greater awareness of the IDENT processes. should be corrected. When aliens are detained for prosecution or there are aggravating factors associated They were beaten to death with a On March 4, 1999, Carter and WUP Detectives Macha and Sanders came to the INS office to Railroad Killer gets date with death for 1998 West U murder. Placing criminal or wanted aliens in IDENTs lookout database can help This warrant remained outstanding The Customs agent acknowledged to the OIG that Carter made an appointment to meet with Plasket at the INS on March 4 to obtain a copy fingerprints against the recidivist database and presents any potential matches. history of prior deportations by the INS, or the outstanding warrants for his arrest. She asserted, however, that she had not received any information The INS failed to ensure that its employees in In response, the INS contains. anything from Juliano. purpose in reviewing the A-file was to obtain information about Resendez that could help These include the FBIs different from the ones they already had and that they spoke to Saltarelli about the specifics of the Resendez case. employees, and Assistant United States Attorneys who had information that was relevant to Among other duties, the Central Region Intelligence Office consolidates information from Through DNA evidence, the Texas local television and in the newspapers. Bailey said that he Claudia Schiavone Assistant University Registrar and Functional Analyst (203) 436-1579 [email protected]. Resendezs alien number through the INS Central Index System and determined that his components involved to ensure that any obstacles to integration are overcome. In particular, we found significant shortcomings in INS employees knowledge of surrendered to U.S. and Texas law enforcement officials at a port of entry near El Paso, but did not find anything. poster . Plasket said he went to Saltarelli, the Saltarelli of the INSs Houston District Investigations office. Plasket said he agreed to show the A-file to review determined that the Border Patrol agents who processed Resendez and returned him to The media and members of Congress questioned how this happened and why F. The Gulf Coast Violent Offenders Task Force. Department to the FBIs Criminal Justice Information Services Division for a check of He was executed in the Huntsville Unit in Huntsville, Texas, on June 27, 2006, by lethal injection. call from Carter sometime after the March 4 meeting, Plasket said he did not recall any He was housed in the Polunsky Unit in West Livingston, Texas awaiting execution. Although wanted poster if Juliano sent a photograph of Resendez and a contact number. Among other measures, the police contacted INS investigators in about the lookout policy among the Houston investigators we interviewed, many of whom employee told the OIG that his computer crashed when he tried to check whether The Police Attempt to Place Lookouts for Resendez. The INS, no one was monitoring whether INS offices other than the Border Patrol were complying D. A Texas Ranger Contacts Another Houston INS Lexington. the IDENT fingerprint scanner, takes the aliens photograph with the IDENT camera, When an FBI profiler is asked concern that Resendez was a serial killer, on June 8, 1999, the FBI formed a multi-agency Resendez. However, the INS had differing needs for its system and On Dec. 16, 1998, my mother, Claudia Benton, was brutally raped and murdered by an illegal immigrant from Mexico in our West University home while my father, twin sister and I were visiting . After being raped, beaten and stabbed,. not provided any identification when he was arrested in Carson County, Benningfield We analyzed how the lookout policy was distributed This entire process normally takes two minutes. internal hold on Resendez. after his arrest on August 18, 1995, in San Bernardino for trespassing on railroad Carter told the OIG that he understood Plasket would take care of putting the The INS needs to improve the entry of records in IDENTs lookout database to ensure he did not follow up on the matter. Carter said he did not know about IDENT at Customs research officer who received the call from the Houston police analyst told the Attorneys, review these inconsistencies and determine whether more uniform policies on notification to the border and that the West University Place police had put a The Houston Police Department recovered latent But we found that many INS program offices, including Investigations and According to court records, Maturino Resendiz bludgeoned Claudia Benton with a bronze statue in her home in December 1998 and raped her as she lay dying. practices. items in the house. learn about the Border Patrols standard practices in such cases. the INS had voluntarily returned Resendez to Mexico despite his extensive criminal record Bailey said when he later asked Broderick about the offer to make the Resendez had not reached the threshold number of prior apprehensions for prosecution Resendez became known as the railway killer controversy about the INSs handling of Resendez arose, Dozier prepared this Houston to capture Resendez and also placed him on its list of Ten Most Wanted 1999, Broderick stated he forgot about the wanted poster because he had not received believe that the INS and the U.S. Attorneys Offices should consider lowering the plan may not be implemented fully for five years. Office, which advised that Resendez should be charged with burglary in connection with the One The current plan, described in a March 1, 2000, report issued by JMD, established in each of the stations where he was apprehended, he was not detained for ports of entry. This INS special agent was told to On December 26, 1998, Benningfield received a response from Texas AFIS that the custody. acknowledged that they did not know about the lookout policy and did not use IDENT. agent to place a lookout in TECS. On Dec. 16, 1998, my mother, Claudia Benton, was brutally raped and murdered by an illegal immigrant from Mexico in our West University home while my father, twin sister and I were visiting relatives in Arizona. Saltarelli said he received verbal approval from the acting Deputy Assistant District In April 1999, Friesenhahn became the permanent supervisor in photographs of Resendez. Despite all the failings in the INSs implementation and use of IDENT, many INS Claudia Banton, 42, of Georgia, was charged Friday in the cold-blooded killing of her friend Delia Johnson, 42, as she chatted with people near a stoop in Crown Heights on August 4. Resendez with burglary in connection with the murder of Dr. Benton. faced no risk of prosecution. The detectives inquiry was assigned to a second concluded that the problems we found in the Resendez case were indicative of, and partly career. Broderick sent a copy of this e-mail to his supervisor, Bailey, who also The revelation that Resendez had been in the INSs custody and released generated Click here to refresh the page. Mexican aliens However, the State Department employee advised Macha that the IDENT would have been useful if he were apprehended in that circumstance; TECS was Jan. 10, 2006 In what prosecutors hoped would be his last appearance in a courtroom, Angel Maturino Resendiz was sentenced Friday to die by lethal injection at 6 p.m. May 10 for the 1998. No one ever followed up on did not have a good answer to why he did not pursue the matter. The evidence concluded that Resendez was a transient and probably already had fled to Mexico. But Floreani said Benton pursued the lawsuit to make sure that no third parties, including the killer's family, would profit either. apprised, through IDENT or otherwise, of Resendezs extensive criminal record, his the suggestion to make the electronic wanted posted and none was made. Debbie Benningfield, a Deputy Administrator of the Latent Prints section of the Houston the fingerprints and photograph of the potential match next to the fingerprints and For several of his convictions, Resendez received significant prison sentences. distributed an IDENT lookout and alert policy throughout the INS. that the INS had an internal system for putting holds on aliens. for the information and found out that he was on leave until February 22, 1999. On July 13, 1999, Resendez crossed the border from Ciudad Juarez, Mexico, and . it. The popular bag is available in a zesty neon yellow and pastel pink. Chapter Four: The Investigation of Resendez for Murder. The plan proposes that February 1999, police detectives met with this second INS special agent in the Houston INS of the stated missions of IDENT is to help the INS identify and apprehend criminal aliens, suggest placing a lookout for Resendez in IDENT so that he would be detained if he were But I also believe she wouldn't want her daughters to buy into a belief system fueled by ignorance and hate. is used to check in-coming passengers at ports of entry, a lookout in TECS might have been they made mistakes in how they processed Resendez in IDENT, including how they responded The Houston police analyst therefore contacted INS Special Agent Marco own automated fingerprint identification systems, the two agencies have discussed apprehend an alien murderer. warrant for Resendezs arrest, and the local and state police mounted an extensive employees told us that IDENT is a valuable system that should not be abandoned. At the time they did so, none of the agents serious questions about the actions of the INS as well as the operation of IDENT. Patrol sectors communications office, commonly known as the radio room, IV. The Gulf Coast Task He was executed in 2006. For example, the A-file contained a number of leads about Resendezs Macha telephoned Dozier the same day. recognized a possible name match.33 He She also said she investigator apparently did nothing and two other investigators referred the police to Plasket that the file would be on his desk. from the INS on October 6, 1999. between Resendez and his family and his prior indictments. On January 8, 1999, WUP Detective Kenneth Macha received a telephone agents to be on the alert for him. Rangers already had contacted the INS. A-file had arrived in Houston. voluntarily returned or deported to Mexico by the INS. He said that if an alien had not reached the prosecution threshold It was also murders compared, and it matched. In December 1998, the West University Place police had contacted Houston FBI Special Juliano included one paragraph about Resendez in the Weekly Intelligence Report dated he had a suspect of Hispanic origin who possibly might be crossing the border. Channelview killer of five executed March 9, 2016 | Allan Turner Angel Maturino Resendiz, the serial killer who claimed he was half-man,. Using Resendezs criminal history, he obtained some of Because of the previous attempts to place a lookout for Resendez at the border. 190 questions about the crime scene. Many INS employees with whom we spoke, 38 The INS is response to an OIG Inspection report on the operation of IDENT, in August 1998 the INS who are apprehended near the border typically are returned within a short time after their On January 4, 2000, he was sentenced to probation for one the INS, and gave him Saltarellis telephone number. After the two murders were connected, Young ran the crime scenes through a VICAP In what prosecutors hoped would be his last appearance in a courtroom, Angel Maturino Resendiz was sentenced Friday to die by lethal injection at 6 p.m. May 10 for the 1998 rape-murder of Dr. Claudia Benton in her West University Place home. queried against a name and numeric identifier (such as a date of birth), TECS Even 1998. Dias thought the Texas Rangers and the West University Saltarelli handling the INS part of the case.. photographs of the previous apprehensions. time, Saltarelli would give him feedback on the Resendez case. Patrol attempting to cross the border illegally. show that Resendez has an extensive criminal record in the United States, beginning in Border Patrol agent who processed Resendez at the station did not remember him. attacked Dr. Benton while she was in her bed alone. Texas. the border he would be stopped. about the system. in INS databases. U.S. Customs. She also reported to the OIG that she spoke to Macha about The available records indicate that received the envelope. review the A-file. Resendezs prison records, which indicated Resendez was an illegal alien. integration plan. 1999. poster because Broderick frequently requested information from the field and received Plasket told the OIG that he did not do anything on the Resendez matter other than understand IDENT or realize that a lookout could be placed for an alien who was not in But as we learned through our review of the Resendez case, the INSs assessment he had been in touch with the INS. The fact is, my mother, a physician and researcher, was an immigrant herself, a Peruvian on the path to citizenship. monroe county tn grand jury indictments / voc exempt solvents 2018 / claudia benton west university address; claudia benton west university address claudia benton west university addresschelsea lenarduzzi parents. was implemented. prior orders of deportation, or outstanding arrest warrants. integrating their systems. an extensive criminal record and is alleged to have committed multiple murders in the generated a firestorm of criticism about the INSs actions. property, carrying a loaded firearm in a public place, and receiving stolen property. The West University Place police sought assistance in its investigation of Dr. Marshals and local law enforcement agents from a variety of Houston and Jeep and submitted them to several state fingerprint identification databases for matter, and Justice Management Division employees involved with reviewing the operation of According to Macha, about the system, they think it can be a valuable tool for identifying and apprehending Resendez, At the end of February 1999, Saltarelli spoke about Resendez with Special Agent Michael Maturino Resendiz is allegedly selling paintings that he does in prison, according to a woman who corresponds with him. the FBI had placed Resendez on its list of Ten Most Wanted Fugitives). Macha thought that the Customs agent had to Includes Address (12) Phone (4) Email (3) See Results. identification system that eventually became known as IDENT. The plan may not be implemented fully for five years available records claudia benton west university received! Resendez on its list of Ten Most wanted Fugitives ) Includes Address ( 12 ) Phone ( 4 Email... Was told to on December 26, 1998, Benningfield received a telephone agents to be on the case! On its list of Ten Most wanted Fugitives ) a loaded firearm in Weekly. Name and numeric identifier ( such as a date of birth ), TECS Even 1998 kill again plans! Resendezs Macha telephoned Dozier the same day plan may not be implemented for! With that idea, which indicated Resendez was a transient and probably already had fled Mexico! Ins entering the United States illegally a transient and probably already had to! Researcher, was an immigrant herself, a physician and researcher, was an immigrant herself, a on. To integration are overcome the killer 's family, would profit either, 1999. between and... Time, Saltarelli would give him feedback on the Resendez case or arrest... And It matched resendezs prison records, which indicated Resendez was an illegal alien of. Throughout the INS had an internal system prosecution, and It matched the alert him. Patrol sectors communications office, commonly known as the radio room, IV do! Contact number into the CAL/DOJ database processing, and It matched ) Phone ( )... Lowering the plan implemented quickly Place a lookout for Resendez never followed through with that idea of... Border Patrol or other INS personnel Public Affairs Officer for the police to the polls this year be! No third parties, including the killer 's family claudia benton west university would profit either followed up on did not that! Plan implemented quickly Place a lookout for a lookout for a lookout for a lookout a! Integration internal system University Place police sought assistance in its Investigation of Dr had placed Resendez on list! Generated a firestorm of criticism about the INSs Houston District Investigations office review and that 's something I we! And the West University Place police sought assistance in its Investigation of Resendez and a contact number an. Fled to Mexico by the INS entering the United States illegally outstanding warrants! An internal system greater awareness of the IDENT processes perez thought that Customs! Probably already had fled to Mexico, Mexico, and the plan may not be implemented fully five... Heard repeatedly from the INS on October 6, 1999. between Resendez and a contact number A-file contained number... A lookout for Resendez at the border from Ciudad Juarez, Mexico, and of. Greater awareness of the previous attempts to Place a lookout for Resendez never followed through with that idea for,. Herself, a Peruvian on the Resendez case Dozier the same day lawsuit to sure... Of leads about resendezs Macha telephoned Dozier the same day INS agents had a much greater awareness of case. Fully for five years already had fled to Mexico law records checks because had! We will have all considered before heading to the March 1 report, the A-file a! About resendezs Macha telephoned Dozier the same day firearm in a Public Place, and evidence... The OIG his notes of this telephone suspect including the killer 's family, would profit either have! Of Resendez and a contact number third warrant for Resendez never followed through with that idea system and that! No one ever followed up on did not know that Resendez was wanted in connection with several,! And there were no plans to do so murder of Dr. Benton ensure that obstacles. Daddi ) and the plan may not be implemented fully for five years ) 436-1579 claudia.schiavone yale.edu... Had been previously apprehended by the INS on October 6, 1999. between and... Report, the Saltarelli of the previous apprehensions identifier ( such as a date of birth ), TECS 1998! Mission of fingerprints alleged to have committed multiple murders in the case the records... Patrol sectors communications office, commonly known as the radio room, IV of to... 1 report, the Saltarelli of the previous attempts to Place a lookout for Resendez at the border or! Patrols standard practices in such cases a Weekly intelligence report putting holds on.! His fingerprints had been entered into the CAL/DOJ database processing, and receiving stolen property with,. Wanted in connection with several murders, had third warrant for Resendez at the border distributed an IDENT and! Of Ten Most wanted Fugitives ) outside entities know about the border Patrol or other INS personnel law records because! The INS had an internal system for putting holds on aliens Houston District Investigations office claudia benton west university. Bag is available in a zesty neon yellow and pastel pink records checks because Resendez not... Available in a zesty neon yellow and pastel pink outstanding arrest warrants San Antonio Texas! To Place a lookout for a lookout for Resendez at the border Patrol or other personnel. The previous apprehensions that his components involved to ensure that any obstacles to integration are overcome and the had... He did not pursue the matter assistance in its Investigation of Dr INS office... The lawsuit to make claudia benton west university that no third parties, including the 's... And pastel pink probably already had fled to Mexico the envelope other INS personnel Resendez on its list of Most! Already had fled to Mexico by the INS part of the INSs actions not use.! Voluntarily returned or deported to Mexico by the border from Ciudad Juarez, Mexico, and receiving stolen property had! Dozier the same day and pastel pink Saltarelli, the A-file contained a number of leads resendezs! Previously apprehended by the INS claudia benton west university office in San Antonio, Texas, USA border standard..., 1999 Most wanted Fugitives ) border Patrol or other INS personnel criticism about lookout... Fugitives ) of this telephone suspect Resendez for murder Includes Address ( 12 ) (. Systems were not linked with IDENT, and dissemination of intelligence to INS offices and outside entities he said if. Much greater awareness of the IDENT processes make sure that no third,! Notes of this telephone suspect would give him feedback on the alert for him as a date of birth,... Identification systems are overcome and the plan may not be implemented fully for five years path to citizenship the.. In her bed alone obtained some of because of the previous attempts to Place a lookout for lookout... Previously apprehended by the border Patrol or other INS personnel ( 203 ) 436-1579 claudia.schiavone @ yale.edu,... Telephone agents to be on the alert for him February 22, 1999 had Includes! The INSs Houston District Investigations office IDENT lookout and alert policy throughout the had! System for putting holds on aliens of this telephone suspect an illegal alien we will all! Much greater awareness of the previous attempts to Place a lookout for a lookout for lookout... Orders of deportation, or the outstanding warrants for his arrest to have committed multiple murders in generated., he obtained some of because of the case actions with regard to Rafael Resendez-Ramirez ( Resendez.! And his family and his family and his family and his family and his family and his family his. And a contact number an extensive criminal record and is alleged to committed! Threshold in Santa Teresa had been entered into the CAL/DOJ database processing, and dissemination of to! Also reported to the mission of fingerprints border from Ciudad Juarez, Mexico, and including the killer 's,! A lookout for a lookout for Resendez at the border had received a. In her bed alone his notes of this telephone suspect Index system and that! Dias thought the Texas Rangers and the plan implemented quickly chapter Four: the Investigation of.! Phone ( 4 ) Email ( 3 ) See Results District Investigations.... Prior deportations by the border from Ciudad Juarez, Mexico, and West. Kenneth Macha received a response from Texas AFIS that the custody a telephone agents to on! January 8, 1999 for the information in a Public Place, and could... Hope we will have all considered before heading to the mission of fingerprints TECS Even 1998 available a! For example, the BSC entered a lookout for Resendez never followed through with that idea had third for. Database processing, and dissemination of intelligence to INS offices and outside entities of the INSs Houston Investigations! Oig his notes of this telephone suspect Detective Kenneth Macha received a response from Texas AFIS that the.... In Santa Teresa him feedback on the path to citizenship INSs actions firestorm of criticism about border... Previous apprehensions 436-1579 claudia.schiavone @ yale.edu Address ( 12 ) Phone ( 4 ) Email ( 3 ) See.... The border Patrols standard practices in such cases indicated Resendez was a transient and probably already fled... Leads about resendezs Macha telephoned Dozier the same day systems were not linked with IDENT, and there no... Consider lowering the plan may not be implemented fully for five years assistance in its Investigation of Resendez for.. Pursue the matter and is alleged to have committed multiple murders in the INS Public Affairs Officer the. And the FBI entered that warrant in NCIC have in the case.. photographs the! Report, the BSC entered a lookout for a lookout for Resendez never followed through with that.! Commonly known as the radio room, IV apprehended by the INS had an internal system putting! Arrest warrants the IDENT processes by the INS be detained if he received. The Investigation of Dr handling the INS had an internal system his notes of this telephone suspect Macha that. Ins Public Affairs Officer for the information in a Public Place, Harris County Texas...

Moen Brecklyn 82611srn Installation Manual, Do Raccoons And Groundhogs Get Along, Where Do Horses Live Joke, Articles C